What follows is a most horrifying Halloween tale. I am sure some of you will find the story amusing and resort to giggles, but that would only be the ones among you that are evil and beyond all hope. The rest of you, those who are innately good, will understand and feel the horror that left an unfortunate five-year-old boy, me, scarred for life.
I awoke that fateful Halloween morning in a state of ignorant bliss. There was no sense of foreboding, no Hitchcockian background music playing that warned me of my impending doom. I guess, looking back, I should have known. My mother had been busy for weeks at the sewing machine constructing something bright red with white polka dots. She had been calling me in from the yard to measure various parts of my anatomy, which I thought strange but no stranger than any of her previous behavior. She was a parent, and, thus by definition, strange. I had learned, like most kids, to accept this and not to question it. A parent’s strangeness was to be tolerated…asking too many questions never led to enlightenment but could result in being sent to your room without dessert. But perhaps I should have taken more notice of my mother’s cheerful disposition that morning. Well, not really her cheerful disposition; she was always a morning person, flitting around in a caffeine high with a joviality that wasn’t quite fitting normal human behavior. It was more the way she stopped, mid flit, and looked down at me with her head cocked at a slight angle and smiled…and then giggled. I looked down. My fly was zipped. I had no idea what the silly woman was giggling about, so I made the mistake of ignoring her. She was obviously crazy, and I had better things to do. For one thing, I had to get my Halloween costume ready.
My plan was to be a vampire. I took a torn t-shirt and went to work bloodying it up with a tube of Acrylic #637 blood-red paint. I had surreptitiously acquired some of my father’s Brylcreem and some eyeliner from my mom’s dresser. I would finish the costume with blue jeans, white socks, penny loafers, and a set of Dracula choppers I had bought at the 5&10. I would be James Dean with fangs. All the other kids would be in awe of my coolness…the girls would swoon and be powerless under my penetrating gaze. I would be the hit of the Halloween party.
Just before noon, my brother came into my room to show off his costume. He was a cowboy. He had this silly hat on that came with a drawstring. It was decidedly uncool. Clint Eastwood wouldn’t be caught dead in such a hat. Nor would Clint Eastwood be caught in that shirt, which sported little bronco-riding, lasso-twirling cowboys. The rest of the ensemble was equally goofy. It consisted of a silver-studded black leather vest with matching chaps, a baby-blue bandana tied around his neck, a two-gun holster strapped to his waist, and the silliest looking pair of red pointy-toed boots. He looked like Roy Rogers only gayer. Imagine Liberace at a rodeo. I looked him up and down and shook my head. How, I wondered, was I related to this dork?
I told him to wait downstairs and I would be down shortly to show him what Halloween was all about. In response, he drew his six-shooters and filled me with holes, and then awkwardly attempted to twirl them back into the holster. After bending down to pick them up, he made a less than gallant exit. This was going to be no contest. I hadn’t planned on dressing up so early but the Twinkle-Toed Kid needed to be shown who’s boss. I donned my outfit, primped a bit until I was happy with the finished look, and struck a few poses. I was devastating. I emanated cool. Cool dripped from me in Acrylic #637 drops. All I needed was a cigarette to dangle from the corner of my mouth, and a few minutes of craftsmanship later, I had one. I was ready. I would make the campy cowboy quake, not just in fear but also in defeat.
When I got downstairs, my brother was eating a grilled cheese sandwich in the dining room. Not exactly cowboy grub, I thought. I snuck up behind him and hovered. My mother spotted me hovering from the kitchen and shrieked, which startled my brother into looking around to see what my mother was shrieking about. His already wide eyes landed on my fangs and it was as if he’d been shot out of a cannon. He headed for the kitchen, and, since the dining room table was between him and the kitchen, it went, too. Success. I was so happy with myself, and I was enjoying a grand chuckle about it when I heard my mom say, “Unh-uh, no you don’t! You go wash that crap off. Your mother made you a Halloween costume and you’re gonna wear it.”
I stopped laughing, which evidently was my brother’s cue to start laughing. “You’re going to be a clown,” he said, very smugly. And one look at my mother confirmed he was right. I tried to protest but mother would not be swayed. “I’ve been working on that clown suit for weeks,” she said, “and you’re going to look so cute in it.”
Oh god…Cute! The c-word. I wanted to die.
Four hours of pulling, adjusting, squishing, and poofing later, I was a little red polka-dotted clown. This included a tall, conical-shaped red hat topped by a white cotton ball and red slippers that elongated from the toe and curled to a point about a foot up in the air. As if that were not enough, there were little bells hanging from the slippers’ pointy tips. My face was painted white with red circles on my cheeks and on my nose was attached a large red ball. When mother was finally satisfied with how ridiculous I looked, I waddled to the mirror. The suit was made to look like it was inflated, which resulted in me looking like a giant ball with a head and two curly feet sticking out. My hands protruded at 45-degree angles and rested on my round little body. It was humiliating. My brother stuck his head through the door and shot me three times. Then he blew the smoke from the tip of the barrel, winked, and disappeared again. I hated him. But when I looked back at the mirror, I found myself wishing his toy gun had indeed been lethal and capable of putting me out of this misery. Jeez. I looked like a giant testicle with chickenpox.
I went over to sit on the end of my mother’s bed to contemplate my situation. My mother shrieked again. She hadn’t decided if sitting was permissible in this costume and she mulled it over. I had to wonder why she was so proud of herself. She had constructed a costume that was not only next to impossible to walk in, it was evidently also impossible to sit down in. Finally, she let me sit but told me to be very careful. I promised her I would, and then secretly wished it would rip. Unfortunately, it didn’t. What it did do, however, was prove, as if it wasn’t abundantly clear already, that my mother had not thought the mechanics of this costume through. As I eased down on the bed, the suit squished upwards and consumed my head so that all that remained was a fat body with a pointy hat sticking out. The squishing effect also raised my arms from the 45-degree angle out to 90-degrees. Though I couldn’t see anything from this new vantage point, I sensed that I had far surpassed looking ridiculous. I must have looked like a huge zit, the little white cotton ball on the tip of my hat being the whitehead. There was, however, one good aspect to this, I thought. While sitting down, no one would ever be able to recognize me short of taking my fingerprints, my stubby little fingers being the only visible evidence that this red ball of polka dots contained a person.
My mother took all this in and started to laugh. Oh, she thought it was so hilarious. She thought it was so funny she called my brother in so he could laugh at me, too. He was most obliging. Then she decided it was so adorable that she had to have a picture. I heard a click here and a click there in between her and my brother’s laughs and an occasional mention of the c-word. My humiliation was complete. I hated them both. I consoled myself with thoughts of fratricide and matricide. Okay, I probably wouldn’t kill my mother—she was useful when it came to putting food on the table—but I decided then and there that any Oedipal complex was out of the question.
And, I suddenly remembered, my humiliation wasn’t near complete. We would next go out in public to trick-or-treat and then to a Halloween party. This meant there would be witnesses. People and, worse, friends would see me portray a pox-ridden testicle, and I wouldn’t have any choice but to allow them to live to tell about it. First, we went to the neighbors’ houses by foot. My brother danced around me, shooting everything in sight, as I waddled slowly along. The little bells on the tips of my curly slippers went kaching-ching kaching-ching, alerting everyone to turn around and stare, but the giant red ball wobbling its way along the sidewalk was so hard not to notice that most people were staring already. I could sense that every car coming down the street slowed so that they, too, could stare, and I was convinced the cars contained each and every friend I had from school. At each house, I would stand and accept the smiles, laughs, and the inevitable barrage of words like “cute” and “adorable” with concealed disdain. My mother, holding my candy bag because it was impossible for me to do so and walk at the same time, beamed with pride. The worst houses we visited were the ones with steps up to the front door, which, in our neighborhood, seemed to be every house. There was no way for me to negotiate the steps with six-inch legs, so I had to submit to the extra humiliation of having my mother lift me by my armpits and carry me up and down each set of steps. Meanwhile, my brother, ever the cowboy, took to herding me. I had to listen to “git along little doggie” and “Yeehaw!” as we progressed from house to house. I kept wishing he would “giddy up” between me and the street…surely no one would suspect foul play if I had stumbled and gave him a slight nudge into oncoming traffic, would they? But before I got my chance, we were finished with our trick-or-treating and back at our house. By this time, dad was home and we immediately loaded into the car to go to the party. I say immediately but it took them five whole minutes to get me into the car. I sat there with my head disappeared into the heart of the beast and felt happy that nobody would be able to identify me as the big bulbous zit in the back seat. Of course, that security lasted only a bit and after another five minutes of easing me out of the car, we were at the party.
The party was hell. Not only was I subjected to endless repetitions of the c-word and “Oh, how adorable,” I was also made to endure cheek pinches from every adult female at the party. My mother couldn’t have been happier. Go ahead, woman, I thought, enjoy yourself…but just how long do you think it will take me to make your sewing machine disappear? I turned to escape from my mom and her friends and the first thing I saw was Cindy Harris, the prettiest and most popular girl at school, coming in the door with her parents. She was dressed, most appropriately, as a princess, and she was walking in my direction. I panicked. Remembering the effect that sitting had on the suit, I grabbed a handful of fabric on both sides and lifted. From Cindy’s vantage point, the red ball’s legs elongated by six inches and its head disappeared, leaving nothing but the conical hat extruding above. I was like a turtle disappearing into my shell. If I had just stood still everything would have been fine, but I didn’t stand still. I suddenly realized that, while I had succeeded in concealing my identity, I had also morphed my clown suit into what appeared to be a huge zit. I had to escape. I turned in what I approximated to be 180 degrees and started to run, or the closest I could come to running with what was now 12-inch legs. I didn’t get far. What I hadn’t realized was that 180 degrees pointed me directly at a wall, which brought my progress to an abrupt halt. I bounced back in the direction I had come and ended up flat on my back. I lay there looking up at the ceiling and wondered how lucky one would have to be for no one to have noticed what just happened. Then I saw Cindy Harris appear, upside down in my vision, standing over me. She looked down and I will never forget what she said…she said, “Oh, it’s you.” And then she turned and calmly walked away. I reached down and pulled on the fabric until my head slipped back into its hiding place. Now I could say it…it was official…my humiliation was complete.
***
[I dedicate this Halloween story to Susan Orlean. I am dedicating it to her because, being the cheap person I am, it doubles as a birthday present. Yes, Halloween is Susan’s birthday. (It sure answers a lot of questions, doesn’t it?) I think the whole world is following Susan on Twitter, but in case you are new to this world, you can find her at http://twitter.com/susanorlean . She is a very special lady. She is a staff writer for the New Yorker magazine and the author of many books. She also has the distinction of being played by Meryl Streep in a Hollywood movie. How many people can say that? Not even Joe Wallace can say that, even though he has offered to shave his beard to make it possible.]
October 29, 2010 at 8:26 pm
I was both horrified and amused. Also, I wish you had those pictures to post.
October 30, 2010 at 5:22 am
Thank you, Toni. Those would be the pictures that my mom showed to every new girlfriend I had. I think it was all a master plan to chase girls out of my life. Oh god, but what fun to look back on.
October 29, 2010 at 9:59 pm
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Kristin Callender, Jonathan Penny, Jonathan Penny, Ashley Moore, Becky Sain and others. Becky Sain said: I'm too scared to even read it! But I will… RT @BlackAddler: A Halloween Horror Story: http://bit.ly/bc06lq NEW POST from The BlackAddler [...]
October 29, 2010 at 10:24 pm
I feel bad for young Jonathan that had to endure this humiliation, but to you Blackaddler, I LMAO!! Sorry, but that is funny. I would find humor in it though, because I am a mom who has made her son walk around in a huge homemade taco costume.
October 30, 2010 at 4:51 am
A taco? WAHAHAHAHA! I won’t say a word about what body part a taco reminds me of, but I imagine your poor son heard all sorts of comments. Hopefully, he was too young to understand.
October 30, 2010 at 2:18 am
Sweet Jesus in a hand basket, that’s absurdly funny. My testicles hurt just laughing at your testicle comment. I’m relieved that I got my story out first – it simply pales. One day, when I’m in that neck of the woods, there will have to be Stellas and the vilification of mothers…
October 30, 2010 at 4:49 am
I loved the imagery in your post. When you became a heap of spasms in a total loss of muscle control, I laughed so hard. It was realistic to what really happens to us when we get the piss scared out of us.
October 30, 2010 at 11:18 am
Thx, but this – “I looked like a giant testicle with chickenpox.” – had me laughing all day. The baristas all thought I was nuts (er, more than usual even).
October 30, 2010 at 2:56 am
Can hardly wait for next year’s installment, My Mom Made Me Into an Ass, in which Our Hero is sadly stuffed into a homemade Eeyore costume, Cindy Harris suggests a game of Pin the Tale on the Donkey, and Susan Orlean (patroness saint of donkeys) again fails to make an appearance.
October 30, 2010 at 4:45 am
That made me laugh. Just waking up—wiping sleep out of my eyes—and the first thing I see is you as Eeyore. A perfect start to the day. I can you and me as Eeyore. You would be the head and my face would appear just under the tail.
October 30, 2010 at 5:12 am
Hysterical. One of my sisters was sent out one Halloween as Stuart Little. My mother made a paper mâché head, framed with chicken wire, and by the end of the evening the eight-year old Stuart-sister had a neck as long as a giraffe because she couldn’t hold her head up anymore. I had gone out as a mummy and came unraveled about half way through the neighborhood and resorted to asking one neighbor for ketchup so I could morph into a wounded soldier.
Great post. Thanks for taking the time to write them.
October 30, 2010 at 5:24 am
LOL…I learned early on that ketchup made poor blood. The problem is it attracts ants, which makes death scenes a misery if done outdoors.
October 30, 2010 at 9:47 am
A clown! Why did it have to be a clown? Clowns are the SCARIEST things of all! (Although a headless clown would be better because it’s their faces that are most terrifying.)
Still. Shudder.
Rest assured. I wouldn’t have thought you were cute. (Though I sometimes do now.)
October 30, 2010 at 10:07 am
My, my, my. What an astute 5 year old boy you were, this explains so, so much. I guess I am beyond hope and evil as I laughed out loud at least 3 times while reading, and since I rarely laugh out loud, is remarkable. I couldn’t help but picture you as an older Stewie Griffin while reading this. Ha! Love it. And I agree with Judy – clowns are the most terrifying thing, so I guess I do feel a little sorry for that 5 yo Jonathan, maybe I’m not completely evil after all. Also – sorry, but I think this confirms that you are in fact – cute, hmm, no, maybe adorkable. #keepemcoming
October 30, 2010 at 11:11 am
Response to both Caroline and Judy (j):
Pat Murkland (@murkland on Twitter) also mentioned a distaste for clowns. I’ve noticed quite a few people with anti-clown sentiments in recent years, and do recall a few horror films that have taken advantage of this fear, which I just discovered is so popular it has a name…coulrophobia. I feel remiss for not considering this while writing this piece. I should have cleverly made it clear that there was nothing in the least bit scary in my mother’s clown creation…the word it called to mind, I believe quite fairly, was pansy. She couldn’t have made me less pansy-ish had she put me in a ballerina’s tutu.
October 30, 2010 at 11:28 am
I’m a Bozo man, myself. Chuckles, not so much. My mother used to buy my costume, which is a bit distressing in itself.
October 30, 2010 at 11:35 am
Mother’s just don’t get it, do they? I think it is more a holiday for them than for the kids.
October 30, 2010 at 11:31 am
I know I’m going to hell now as I can’t stop laughing!! You HAVE to compile all of your stories into a book!!!
October 30, 2010 at 11:53 am
Well, you’re not alone. It seems most of my friends have wound up in the evil column.
November 2, 2010 at 11:14 am
Poor little clown pimple. xxx
November 10, 2010 at 1:15 pm
I have GOT to start going to the bathroom before I read your posts. You are the only writer who has ever literally had me laughing till I peed my pants. OMG! {My embarrassing admission #1.}
I ADORE 5-year-old Jonathan almost as much as I adore you now. This is more proof of how mature you were for your age. It’s almost beyond belief. I cannot imagine any other child that age coming up with his own costume of a smoking vampire ala James Dean. You would certainly have been devastating and emanating cool at the party and all of the girls would have swooned. The clown/zit/testicle costume may have saved the virginity of one or more of those girls.
At least you grew up to be devastating and the coolest in real life. I’d swoon over you any day. *mwah*